Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revision Previous revision
Next revision
Previous revision
ausip:copyrightremedies [2018/09/10 15:19]
jessiej_87
ausip:copyrightremedies [2019/03/10 13:00] (current)
jessiej_87
Line 1: Line 1:
-# Remedies for infringement ​of copyright+# Remedies for Infringement ​of Copyright
  
-The //Copyright Act// provides that a copyright owner may bring an action for infringement of the copyright. ((s115)(1) ))+The //Copyright Act// provides that a copyright owner may bring an action for infringement of the copyright. ((//CA// s 115)(1) ))
  
-There are a number of remedies available to copyright owners which include civil remedies such as injunctions and damages ((s115(2) )) and remedies available through criminal proceedings. These remedies will be discussed in detail in this chapter.+There are a number of remedies available to copyright owners which include civil remedies such as injunctions and damages ((//CA// s 115(2) )) and remedies available through criminal proceedings. These remedies will be discussed in detail in this chapter.
  
 ## Civil Remedies ## Civil Remedies
Line 13: Line 13:
 ### Injunctions ### Injunctions
  
-An injunction is one of the most common remedies and may either be an interlocutory injunction or a final injunction. An injunction is an equitable remedy which seeks to prevent a person from doing a particular thing or demands a person to do a particular thing.((s115(2))+An injunction is one of the most common remedies and may either be an interlocutory injunction or a final injunction. An injunction is an equitable remedy which seeks to prevent a person from doing a particular thing or demands a person to do a particular thing.((//CA// s 115(2))
  
 An interim injunction (or interlocutory) is granted in a situation where the person seeking the injunction can establish that there is a question which needs to be tried by the court. ((Castlemaine Tooheys Lyd v South Australia (1986) 161 CLR 148)) An interim injunction (or interlocutory) is granted in a situation where the person seeking the injunction can establish that there is a question which needs to be tried by the court. ((Castlemaine Tooheys Lyd v South Australia (1986) 161 CLR 148))
Line 21: Line 21:
 ### Damages ### Damages
  
-Pursuant to the Act, damages is an available remedy and can be awarded in certain circumstances. ((s115(2) ))+Pursuant to the// Act//, damages is an available remedy and can be awarded in certain circumstances. ((//CA// s 115(2) ))
  
-Damages cannot be obtained from an innocent infringer – that is, damages are not available if, at the time of the infringement,​ the defendant was not aware, and had no reasonable grounds for suspecting, that the act constituting the infringement was an infringement of the copyright. ((s 115(3) ))+Damages cannot be obtained from an innocent infringer – that is, damages are not available if, at the time of the infringement,​ the defendant was not aware, and had no reasonable grounds for suspecting, that the act constituting the infringement was an infringement of the copyright. ((//​CA// ​s 115(3) ))
  
-##### Kiama Constructions v MC Casella Building Co Pty Ltd+__//Kiama Constructions v MC Casella Building Co Pty Ltd//​__(((1980) 10 IPR 345))
  
 * The plaintiff builder drew up a plan for a couple to build a house on a block of land.  The couple made a pencil sketch of the plan and showed the defendant builder. ​ The defendant builder suggested a draftsman should draw up more detailed plans. * The plaintiff builder drew up a plan for a couple to build a house on a block of land.  The couple made a pencil sketch of the plan and showed the defendant builder. ​ The defendant builder suggested a draftsman should draw up more detailed plans.
Line 33: Line 33:
 ### Additional Damages ### Additional Damages
  
-Additional damages of a punitive and/or aggravated nature may also be awarded in certain ​circumsatnces. ((s115(4) ))+Additional damages of a punitive and/or aggravated nature may also be awarded in certain ​circumstances. ((//CA// s 115(4) ))
  
 In these instances the court has regard to: In these instances the court has regard to:
  
-(i)  the flagrancy of the infringement;​+(i)  the flagrancy of the infringement;​
  
-(ia)  the need to deter similar infringements of copyright;+(ia)  the need to deter similar infringements of copyright;
  
-(ib)  the conduct of the defendant after the act constituting the infringement or, if relevant, after the defendant was informed that the defendant had allegedly infringed the plaintiff’s copyright;+(ib)  the conduct of the defendant after the act constituting the infringement or, if relevant, after the defendant was informed that the defendant had allegedly infringed the plaintiff’s copyright;
  
     * (ii)  whether the infringement involved the conversion of a work or other subject matter from hardcopy or analogue form into a digital or other electronic machine readable form;     * (ii)  whether the infringement involved the conversion of a work or other subject matter from hardcopy or analogue form into a digital or other electronic machine readable form;
Line 50: Line 50:
  
  
-##### Milpurrurru ​v Indofurn Pty Ltd+__Milpurrurru ​v Indofurn Pty Ltd__(([1994] FCA 1544))
  
-The artwork of eight Aboriginal artists had been reproduced without their permission on carpets manufactured overseas and imported into Australia by the defendants.+The case of [Milpurrurru v Indofurn Pty Ltd](http://​classic.austlii.edu.au/​au/​cases/​cth/​FCA/​1994/​1544.html) involved the artwork of eight Aboriginal artists ​which had been reproduced without their permission on carpets manufactured overseas and imported into Australia by the defendants.
  
-* Held, copyright ​infringement – additional damages were assessed ​at $70,000 having regards to the cultural harm and personal distress caused.+The Court held that copyright ​had been infringed. Further, the Court assessed ​additional dames in the sum of $70,000having regards to the cultural harm and personal distress caused.
  
 ### Account of Profits ### Account of Profits
  
-Pursuant to the //Act//, an account of profits is an available remedy. ((s115(2) ))+Pursuant to the //Act//, an account of profits is an available remedy. ((//CA// s 115(2) ))
  
-An account of profits is an alternative remedy to damages and the applicant must choose which they will be seeking. An account of profits provides for the applicant to recover a sum which represents that proportion of the respondent’s profits that was fairly attributable to the infringement of the applicant’s copyright. ((//Robert J Zupanovich v B & N Beale Nominees//​))+An account of profits is an alternative remedy to damages and the applicant must choose which they will be seeking. An account of profits provides for the applicant to recover a sum which represents that proportion of the respondent’s profits that was fairly attributable to the infringement of the applicant’s copyright. ((//Robert J Zupanovich v B & N Beale Nominees ​Pty// [1995] FCA 1424))
  
 ### Conversion Damages ### Conversion Damages
  
-There is also another remedy available known as conversion damages. ((s116))+There is also another remedy available known as conversion damages. ((//CA// s 116))
  
 In conversation,​ the plaintiff takes control of infringing copies or devices used in the making of infringing copies. ​ In conversation,​ the plaintiff takes control of infringing copies or devices used in the making of infringing copies. ​
Line 70: Line 70:
 These provisions were substantially amended by the //Copyright Amendment Act (No 1) 1998// with the effect of making the remedy a matter of discretion by the court. ​ These new provisions are intended to avoid the possibility of the award of excessive damages. These provisions were substantially amended by the //Copyright Amendment Act (No 1) 1998// with the effect of making the remedy a matter of discretion by the court. ​ These new provisions are intended to avoid the possibility of the award of excessive damages.
  
-An owner of copyright in a work or other subject-matter may bring an action for conversion or detention in relation to: ((s116(1) ))+An owner of copyright in a work or other subject-matter may bring an action for conversion or detention in relation to: ((//CA// s 116(1) ))
  
 * an infringing copy. * an infringing copy.
  
-An "​infringing copy" is defined as an article, the making of which constituted an infringement of copyright in the work, sound recording, film, broadcast or edition, as the case may be, or in the case of an imported article would have constituted such an infringement if the article had been made in Australia by the importer. ((s10(1) ))+An "​infringing copy" is defined as an article, the making of which constituted an infringement of copyright in the work, sound recording, film, broadcast or edition, as the case may be, or in the case of an imported article would have constituted such an infringement if the article had been made in Australia by the importer. ((//CA// s 10(1) ))
  
 * a device used for making infringing copies. * a device used for making infringing copies.
  
  
-A court may grant those remedies that would be available as if: ((s116(1A) ))+A court may grant those remedies that would be available as if: ((//​CA// ​s116(1A) ))
  
 * the copyright owner had been the owner of the infringing copy since the time the copy was made. * the copyright owner had been the owner of the infringing copy since the time the copy was made.
  
-* the owner of the device used or intended for use in making them.+* the owner of the device ​was used or intended for use in making them.
  
  
-Conversion damages is a remedy in addition to, for example, compensatory damages. ((s116(1B) )) But, the court is not to make an award for conversion damages where it is satisfied, in essence, that an award of compensatory damages under s 115 is a "​sufficient remedy"​ in the circumstances. ((s116(1C) ))  ​+Conversion damages is a remedy in addition to, for example, compensatory damages. ((//CA// s 116(1B) )) But, the court is not to make an award for conversion damages where it is satisfied, in essence, that an award of compensatory damages under s 115 is a "​sufficient remedy"​ in the circumstances. ((//CA// s 116(1C) ))  ​
  
-In deciding whether to grant conversion damages and in assessing the amount of such damages the court is to have regard, for example, to the expenses incurred by the defendant in manufacturing or acquiring the infringing copy and "any other matter that the court considers relevant"​. ((s116(1D) ))+In deciding whether to grant conversion damages and in assessing the amount of such damages the court is to have regard, for example, to the expenses incurred by the defendant in manufacturing or acquiring the infringing copy and "any other matter that the court considers relevant"​. ((//CA// s 116(1D) ))
  
-If only part of the infringing copy consists of material that infringes copyright, the court considers:​((s116(1E) ))+If only part of the infringing copy consists of material that infringes copyright, the court considers:​((//CA// s 116(1E) ))
  
 * the importance to the market value of the article of the material that infringes copyright. * the importance to the market value of the article of the material that infringes copyright.
Line 98: Line 98:
 * the extent to which the material that infringes copyright may be separated from the article. * the extent to which the material that infringes copyright may be separated from the article.
  
-Conversion damages cannot be obtained from an innocent infringer. A copyright owner is not entitled to conversion damages if it is established that at the time of the conversion that:((s116(2) ))+Conversion damages cannot be obtained from an innocent infringer. A copyright owner is not entitled to conversion damages if it is established that at the time of the conversion that:((//CA// s 116(2) ))
  
 * the defendant was not aware, and no reasonable grounds for suspecting that copyright subsisted in the work or other subject-matter;​ or * the defendant was not aware, and no reasonable grounds for suspecting that copyright subsisted in the work or other subject-matter;​ or
Line 106: Line 106:
 ### Anton Piller Order ### Anton Piller Order
  
-The last civil remedy available to copyright owners is an Anton Piller Order. An Anton Piller Order is an ex parte interlocutory order that requires ​the the defendant to permit the plaintiff’s solicitors to enter their premises forthwith to inspect and remove defined articles and documents.+The last civil remedy available to copyright owners is an Anton Piller Order. An Anton Piller Order is an ex parte interlocutory order that requires the defendant to permit the plaintiff’s solicitors to enter their premises forthwith to inspect and remove defined articles and documents.
  
-In order for an Anton Piller Order to be granted, the plaintiff needs to show a strong prima facie case and there is a real risk that evidence will be destroyed if an order was not made. ((//Anton Piller KG v Manufacturing Processes Ltd//; //Polygram Records Pty Ltd v Monash Records (Australia) Pty Ltd//))+In order for an Anton Piller Order to be granted, the plaintiff needs to show a strong prima facie case that there is a real risk that evidence will be destroyed if an order was not made. ((//Anton Piller KG v Manufacturing Processes Ltd// [1976] Ch. 55 (C.A.); //[Polygram Records Pty Ltd v Monash Records (Australia) Pty Ltd](http://​classic.austlii.edu.au/​au/​cases/​cth/​FCA/​1985/​472.html)//[1985] FCA 472))
  
 ## Criminal Provisions ## Criminal Provisions
Line 116: Line 116:
 Examples of criminal provisions: Examples of criminal provisions:
  
-* commercial-scale infringement prejudicing copyright owner; ((132AC))+* commercial-scale infringement prejudicing copyright owner; ((//CA// s 132AC))
  
-* making infringing copy commercially;​ ((132AD))+* making infringing copy commercially;​ ((//CA// s 132AD))
  
-* selling or hiring out infringing copy; ((132AE))+* selling or hiring out infringing copy; ((//CA// s 132AE))
  
-    ​* offering infringing copy for sale or hire; ((132AF))+* offering infringing copy for sale or hire; ((//CA// s 132AF))
  
-    ​* exhibiting infringing copy in public commercially;​ ((132AG))+* exhibiting infringing copy in public commercially;​ ((//CA// s 132AG))
  
-    ​* importing infringing copy commercially;​ ((132AH)+* importing infringing copy commercially;​ ((//CA// s 132AH))
  
-    ​* distributing infringing copy; ((132AI))+* distributing infringing copy; ((//CA// s 132AI))
  
-    ​* possessing infringing copy for commerce; ((132AJ))+* possessing infringing copy for commerce; ((//CA// s 132AJ))
  
-    ​* making or possessing device for making infringing copy; ((132AL))+* making or possessing device for making infringing copy; ((//CA// s 132AL))
  
-    ​* advertising supply of infringing copy; ((132AM))+* advertising supply of infringing copy; ((//CA// s 132AM))
  
-    ​* causing work to be performed publicly; ((132AN)) and+* causing work to be performed publicly; ((//CA// s 132AN)) and
  
-    ​* causing recording or film to be heard or seen in public. ((132AO))+* causing recording or film to be heard or seen in public. ((//CA// s 132AO))
  
  
Line 149: Line 149:
 Strict liability offences do not have a fault element. The maximum penalty for a strict liability offence is 60 penalty units ($6,600) for a natural person. ​ Strict liability offences do not have a fault element. The maximum penalty for a strict liability offence is 60 penalty units ($6,600) for a natural person. ​
  
-Regulations may provide for a scheme of infringement notices (on-the-spot fines) to be issued for strict liability offences up to 20% of the maximum penalty. ((s133B))+Regulations may provide for a scheme of infringement notices (on-the-spot fines) to be issued for strict liability offences up to 20% of the maximum penalty. ((//CA// s 133B))
  
 Regulations in Part 6A of the //Copyright Regulations 1969// set up an infringement notice and forfeiture scheme. Regulations in Part 6A of the //Copyright Regulations 1969// set up an infringement notice and forfeiture scheme.
  • ausip/copyrightremedies.1536556755.txt.gz
  • Last modified: 10 months ago
  • (external edit)